OpenAI wins first round against Raw Story and AlterNet copyright case

OpenAI is dealing with multiple lawsuits over its use of a number of publications’ and books’ content material to coach its giant language fashions with out specific permission or correct compensation. A choose has simply dismissed one among them. New York federal choose Colleen McMahon has dismissed the lawsuit filed by Uncooked Story and AlterNet, which accused the company of utilizing their supplies for AI coaching with out consent. As VentureBeat notes, although, their criticism did not argue that OpenAI infringed on their copyright like different publications’ lawsuits do. As a substitute, it centered on the DMCA provision that protects “copyright administration info.”

The publications argued that OpenAI eliminated the creator names, titles and different metadata figuring out their copyright from the articles it used to coach its LLMs. McMahon defined that the plaintiffs failed to indicate that they suffered “a cognizable damage” from these actions and that the hurt that they had cited was “not the kind of hurt that has been elevated” to warrant a lawsuit. The choose additionally stated that “the probability that ChatGPT would output plagiarized content material from one among [their] articles appears distant.” She added that the plaintiffs are actually in search of redress for the usage of their articles “to develop ChatGPT with out compensation” and never for the removing of their copyright administration info.

Uncooked Story and AlterNet do not intend to again down, based mostly on what their lawyer advised Reuters. Matt Matter, their legal professional, stated they’re “sure [they] can tackle the issues the courtroom recognized by an amended criticism.”